Fab French Insurance
x
LoginLogin
french visas refused vignette

Original research by FAB French Insurance

Imagine the scenario, you’ve found somewhere to live, got all your paperwork together and started planning the move. Then your visa application gets rejected, why?

Sometimes the reasoning might be clear, sometimes less so and very often you’re left with absolutely no idea of which particular element was missing. Or perhaps, it wasn’t even ‘missing’, it just wasn’t quite what they were looking for.

But never fear – we are here to help!

At FAB French Insurance, we’ve gone through 100 refusal letters that applicants have shared with us. We’ve done this to understand the reasons being stated, and to see what applicants can learn from them. Our biggest finding has been that incomplete or unclear information about the purpose of the stay and any associated conditions was far more common than any other reason.

This is very useful information, especially for people applying for a visitor VLS-TS. However, it’s even more interesting when we start to look a little deeper into the rejections.

What we studied and our disclaimer!

In terms of the provenance of the 100 letters, 44 came from French consulates in the UK, 30 from the US, 21 from other non-English-speaking countries and five from other English-speaking countries. It’s important to note that these are the consular locations and not necessarily the applicants’ nationalities. All of the letters came via applicants who had contacted FAB following a refusal. Their reasons for getting in touch were either to ask for a health insurance policy refund or to request assistance to resolve their situation.

At FAB our work mainly involves visitor visas and this accounts for around 80% of our visa-related caseload. This is followed by the talent / entrepreneur categories (18%) and other categories (2%). These percentages relate to our usual business mix, rather than the exact category percentages of the 100 letters in question.

Obviously, we sell insurance which is specifically geared towards meeting visa requirements and this of course, gives us a commercial interest in this subject. It also determines the kind of cases we see; applicants with ‘visa suitable’ insurance cover are going to be less likely to get an insurance related rejection. Some applicants only get in touch once they have been refused and these factors create a degree of bias.

In other words, this information is a descriptive review of cases shared with FAB and not a representative national study! Our research only covers rejected applications, so it can’t predict the likelihood of a visa being refused or compare success rates among different insurance providers and the inclusion of other visa categories also means the findings shouldn’t be seen as exclusively visitor VLS-TS visa results.

So what were the reasons?

The first thing to remember is that a single refusal letter can state more than one reason; the 100 letters contained 108 refusal reasons.

The second thing to note is that the percentages below refer to those 108 reasons, not to all French visa applications.

Visa refusal reasons in 100 FAB French Insurance client letters

FAB French Insurance reviewed 100 visa refusal letters from its own clients and identified 108 recorded refusal reasons. A single letter can contain more than one reason. The percentages below show each category’s share of the 108 recorded reasons, not its share of the 100 letters or of all French visa applications.

FAB French Insurance client dataset: 108 refusal reasons recorded across 100 refusal letters
Recorded refusal reason Number of recorded reasons Share of all 108 recorded reasons (%)
Incomplete or unreliable information about the purpose and conditions of the stay 63 58.33%
Insufficient evidence of resources to cover the stay 19 17.59%
Inadequate or invalid health insurance 11 10.19%
Risk of misuse of the visa: unlawful stay or unlawful activities 8 7.41%
Economic project did not meet the required criteria 5 4.63%
Required professional criteria not met 1 0.93%
Visa category incompatible with the declared project 1 0.93%
Total recorded refusal reasons 108 100%

Percentages are rounded to two decimal places. The displayed category percentages sum to 100.01% because of rounding.

Source, methodology and limitations

Source: FAB French Insurance’s analysis of 100 refusal letters from its own clients. This is a client-based dataset, not an official or representative sample of French visa applications or refusals.

Insurance-related refusal reasons may be underrepresented because FAB is an insurance broker supplying cover intended to meet the relevant visa requirements. This selection effect has not been quantified.

At the time of publication, FAB has not encountered an insurance-related visa refusal involving its main insurance product (Mondial 1st Euro). This statement concerns that product, not every policy associated with the letters in this dataset, and is not a guarantee of visa approval.

Because the dataset contains refusal letters only, it cannot establish an overall visa refusal rate or an individual applicant’s likelihood of refusal.

Looking at this information it is easy to see that by far the biggest number of rejections fall into the first category and are quite simply, applications that leave questions unanswered.

This is frustrating; when you get a refusal letter you can see that the authorities were not satisfied with the information provided, but you may not be able to work out the precise document or inconsistency concerned.

For visitor applications, France-Visas asks for proof of your circumstances, resources, accommodation and medical cover in France, alongside a formal commitment not to undertake any form of professional activity. The supporting documents that you will be asked to provide to prove the above can vary according to your nationality and where you are from.

These documents need to be consistent and clear.

Basic checks to make are:

  • Do your intended dates match with your accommodation arrangements?
  • Is your source of income understandable?
  • Does your insurance cover the stay you describe?

If any of this is even possibly unclear, provide a brief covering explanation; this can help connect the paperwork, but it won’t replace missing evidence so make sure you provide everything that is asked for.

Not every refusal relates to an insurance issue; financial resources, in terms of both having resources and being able to show them, also play a part. 19 of these rejections related to insufficient evidence of resources.

Sometimes there is a genuine shortfall but very often the applicant may well have sufficient funds but they haven’t clearly shown this. You need to show the financial evidence requested in your individual situation and explain anything that could possibly be viewed as not easy to understand. Things like irregular income, a recent large transfer / deposit or just having several accounts might all seem like red flags to the person dealing with your file. Your aim should be to make your financial picture easy for them to understand.

Insurance refusals: What are the possible problems and the practical fixes?

The third largest category was inadequate or invalid health insurance and this showed up 11 times and accounts for about 10% of all rejections. Whilst we don’t yet have a dataset on the individual issues, we do have checks and solutions based on our extensive experience.

Insurance documents: possible issues and practical fixes
Possible issue Practical fix
Cover dates leave a gap or don’t match the proposed stay Check the required coverage period and have the certificate corrected before submission.
A policy excludes the country where you become resident, or limits each trip Obtain written confirmation that it remains valid for your intended stay and residence situation in France.
Benefits, exclusions or deductibles do not meet the application’s requirements Compare the actual policy wording with your personalised checklist; ask the broker to resolve any mismatch.
Required medical or repatriation benefits are missing or unclear Obtain an explicit certificate of the required benefits, or arrange suitable replacement cover.
The evidence supplied is a quotation or does not clearly establish active cover Supply the issued certificate and any requested proof of payment or activation.
Names, dates or address details conflict with other documents Correct errors and explain legitimate differences. Use an accurate French accommodation address where appropriate.
Payment arrangements leave uncertainty about the duration of cover Ask for confirmation of the coverage period and payment terms. If paid annually, include the receipt where helpful.

At FAB we generally recommend annual payment because it makes the payment position straightforward to document. Using a French insurer, making annual payment, and having a French address on the certificate are not legal requirements per se but may all help. Policy price alone doesn’t necessarily prove suitability as an expensive policy can have unsuitable exclusions; equally a “travel insurance” policy may or may not meet a particular application’s requirements. You will need to carefully check the terms, especially relating to residence restrictions and maximum trip duration.

Although our own FAB policy was not cited under the specific insurance-refusal reason in this review, this is an observation and not a guarantee of approval.

The visa must fit the plan

The remaining reasons for refusals include concerns about misuse, business projects, professional qualifications and choosing an incompatible visa category and these are all quite distinct issues. A visitor application that includes plans to work throws up a different issue from an entrepreneur application with a sketchy business plan. France-Visas distinguishes routes according to the purpose of the stay; not every long-stay visa is a VLS-TS.

The Take Away

The most important takeaway from this review is that in order to get a positive answer, you need to choose the correct route, follow the personalised France-Visas checklist and ensure that the supporting evidence is clear, consistent, and verifiable. No insurance policy or presentation ‘hack’ can guarantee a visa but a well-prepared application gives the decision-maker far fewer unanswered questions and this in turn, means that your application is far more likely to lead to a successful result.

Good luck!

Schedule a call with us